Blog

Clove vs Vanilla

Compare Clove (Indonesia) and Vanilla (Madagascar) side by side — origin, maker, price, materials and what the difference actually means.

The short answer

  • Country Indonesia Madagascar
  • Maker Smallholder growers of Maluku and Sulawesi Smallholder growers of the SAVA region
  • Region Maluku Islands and Sulawesi SAVA (Sambava, Antalaha, Vohemar, Andapa)
  • Made since 1770 1841
  • Botanical name Syzygium aromaticum Vanilla planifolia
  • Family Myrtaceae Orchidaceae (the only orchid grown for food)

Side by side

Download as PDF
Field Clove Vanilla
CountryIndonesiaMadagascar
TypeSpiceSpice
MakerSmallholder growers of Maluku and SulawesiSmallholder growers of the SAVA region
RegionMaluku Islands and SulawesiSAVA (Sambava, Antalaha, Vohemar, Andapa)
Made since17701841
Verified recordYesYes
SourceWikipediaWikipedia
Botanical nameSyzygium aromaticumVanilla planifolia
FamilyMyrtaceaeOrchidaceae (the only orchid grown for food)
Commodity code (HS)0907090510

Clove

Cloves are flower buds that never opened, from a tree native to five small islands in the Moluccas. Indonesia grows more than anyone and exports only ten to fifteen per cent of it, sometimes importing from Madagascar to cover the shortfall. The rest goes into cigarettes.

  • Cloves are the aromatic flower buds of Syzygium aromaticum, a tree in the family Myrtaceae, native to the Maluku Islands of Indonesia
  • Eugenol makes up 72-90% of the essential oil extracted from cloves and is the compound most responsible for its aroma
  • Indonesia is the largest clove producer, but only about 10-15% of its production is exported, and domestic shortfalls are sometimes filled with imports from Madagascar
  • Most of Indonesia's crop goes into kretek, the clove cigarette; the United States reclassified clove cigarettes as cigars in 2009 after banning flavoured cigarettes
  • Until the colonial era cloves grew only on a few islands in the Moluccas: Bacan, Makian, Moti, Ternate and Tidore

Read the full story of Clove

Vanilla

Vanilla is the seed pod of a climbing orchid that will not set fruit on its own outside Mesoamerica. Every flower on every farm in the world is pollinated by hand, on the one day it opens. That single fact explains the price — and the price has moved from $73 a kilogram to $457 and back to $51 inside a decade.

  • Every vanilla flower grown commercially is pollinated by hand, and each one has to be done within twelve hours of opening
  • The flower of Vanilla planifolia lasts about one day, sometimes less, so plantations are inspected every morning of the season
  • A wild vanilla orchid has only about a 1% chance of being pollinated even inside its native range
  • The pod takes five to six weeks to form and around six months to mature, before months of curing
  • An estimated 95% of products flavoured 'vanilla' use vanillin synthesised from lignin rather than the pod

Read the full story of Vanilla